Hey There ...
1) Can you as a teacher really teach students what you know? Is it possible for them to know ideas in the same way that you know them?
On a positive note, I thought being able to look a past students web sites was a great idea and it has helped me generate some of my own ideas about how I want my webpage to look and made me realize some things I should try to do with the program the next time I use it. Also, regarding the articles I read for the previous class, were helpful but very stiff and instructional. I find the best way to learn is to experiment and not to go step by step with an outline of instructions from a book. But, on the other hand, little bit of instruction never hurt anyone and I did learn some useful things that would have been hard to figure just be experimenting.
Week 5 – Web Quests
I was unable to attend this class because I was sick...
So there is no reflection for this week, just the textbook questions...
Textbook Questions:
1)
Are online chats and instant
messaging of value in the classroom? Do they add to student learning, or do
they distract from "real" instruction? What is "real"
instruction?
In my personal experience instant messaging in class has been a huge distraction for me when im trying to stay focus on the lecture and pay attention in class. However, after reading this article I have been informed on ways it can be benefiting to the classroom environment and i have to say I do feel that messaging has value in the classroom. Some ways messaging can be valuable to the classroom is in terms of communication with our students around the world or by providing a faster new way for students to share there ideas in class. Speaking to students across the world would be a faster equivalent to having a ‘pen-pal’, something that would incorporated into school when i was younger. Also, instant messaging can give shy student the ability to speak his mind and comment without being nervous while speaking in front of the entire class.
My concept of "real" instruction is when a teacher guides a classroom and explains for example how to do a math problem, how to turn on a computer, what the importance of an example plays towards what we are learning in the course. If chatting and messaging online is used in productive responsible ways, it can be a great addition to the classroom allowing it run more smoothly without distraction.
2) Can the technologies presented in this chapter be a means of engaging and involving parents in their children's schools? In what ways?
Growing up I always felt my parents were never really involved in my schooling and never could truly understand what I was learning in class. And, as a young kid, I never felt I could explain what I was learning in school properly to my parents. I answer both yes and no to this question, because not all parents are technologically literate, however down the road, this will change.I f parents don’t know how
to use a computer, it will be much harder for them to engage in their
children’s school through this medium. However parents who are able to use the computer well will be much more involved parents in their children’s schools.
Online forums for discussion allow parents to interactively find out about what their student is learning. This allows parents to read posts from class and gain valuable knowledge on the subject their student may need help in. The plus here is that parents are able to keep up to date on the work being done in school and thus they can better take part in their child’s learning. Also, parents will be able to use the online discussion forums and instant messaging to talk to other parents to discuss what is being learned in class, problems with students, field trips and other information that concerns parents and teachers. It acts as a great method of communication between parents and teachers.
3)
Are their benefits to
asynchronous, test-based communication over synchronous, face-to-face
communication? In what situations?
There are many benefits to asynchronous communication, over face-to-face communication. Face-to-face would be considered back and forth conversations like msn messenger. Asynchronous would be like facebook, or discussion boards. At McGill the discussion board is something used in every class on WebCt and it has been extremely beneficial for me. For one, discussion boards allow students to ask questions they maybe wouldn't want to ask in front of the entire class because they were embarrassed or felt it was not relevant to class discussion. Also topics can be posted and a number of different people can give there two-cents of the topic like a class discussion but it can happen over a long period of time. Then someone can come read the discussion and it was almost like there were there listening in class.
4)
In many ways, audio podcasts are like to listening to a radio broadcast. Are radio broadcasts typically used in
classrooms? Why or why not? If not, why would using podcasts be of any greater
value?
I don't feel radiocasts are ever used in the classroom, its because there rarely educational and rarely useful to topics being discussed in class. Podcasts could be useful in class however, because they give freedom to talk about anything and there is a much wider range of topics being discussed. Also a podcast could be a great way for students to do research and do an oral presentation. So again they don't have to do it in front of the class and the students could listen to the podcast as homework and talk notes. Instead of doing presentations in front the class students could download the weekly podcasts and listen. Also classes could be recorded and put on a podcast so if a student misses class he can listen to what he missed, or if a student didn't understand a concept he can relisten to it and hopefully understand it then.
Week 6 – Collaborative Writing
This week in class our goal was to complete three assignments. I liked this class more then most others because we were given the freedom to work at our own pace in order to complete the assignments.
The first assignment we had was an online scavenger hunt which was more enjoyable then the others but at the same time kind of childish. You told us it was an assignment you used for grade 6's and really im not actually sure why you make us complete it. Even for grade 6's i feel the assignment is kind of pointless and I think there are better ways to learn how to use programs and do research and think critically. The next exercise was boring and even more time consuming. This is assignment i really felt had no value whatsoever to what we are learning in class... We had to essentially the correcting of sentences and certain phrases as well as other analytical word based problems. Overall I felt this entire assignment to be boring, a waste of time and very tedious. It kind of turned me off the class, made me lose focus. I still don’t know why we had to do it, so maybe you could explain that.
However I really enjoyed, (because it made me feel like I was in grade 3 again using kid pix) making both Valentines Day cards and the crosswords and word searches. Neither were very challenging, but nonetheless they were fun. The whole process reminded me of my youth and think its a great program to use for children in elementary school... I'll definitely remember it
After the assignments were completed, we were allowed to work on out Web Quest assignments with our partner. FINALLY! Me and my partner formed the basis for the information of our web quest, did some research on the internet surrounding our topic (global warming) and emailed the work home so we could complete during our reading week. This part of the class was the best because we had freedom and we could work at our own pace.
ABOUT THE READING
The reading involved ideas about how writing technology can be used to influence progress in the classroom. The strategies mentioned for how to use writing comprehension in the classroom included: concept maps for organization and a Microsoft Powerpoint presentation. The article discussed the benefits inherit with collaborative writing which include: positive relationships between students, opportunities for peer and self-assessment, and increased participation of students. The article is geared towards prospective teachers and because I don't plan to be one its not the most exciting reading to complete. However, it does get me thinking and sometime I think maybe I might want to be a teacher and think I'd be good at it. Who knows... This class might change my life!
Textbook Questions
#2)
I feel like a good method would be to make assignments for class be posted online so the entire class can see. This would encourage students to produce the best possible work they can because there peers get to review it and they probably wont want to look stupid. However at the same time, depending on the school system your in, this might work negatively. Some students like to have the reputation of being a class clown or a slacker or a trouble maker. These students might then be encouraged to produce lower quality or more humorous assignments because there peers get to see the work. Nevertheless, for the most part this time of method would be productive and I believe the positives out way the negatives. This idea will promote students to produce there best work and allow students to learn from other students.
#4)
Although this was already covered in the question above, I feel that posting assignments for all the students too see and review is a great motivator for students to produce there very best work. Variations of this idea could further boost student productivity. Posting the grades of assignments, giving students ranks, giving bonus incentives for marks based on what is posted would further motivate students to do better based on there peers seeing there marks. When I went to high school everyone in the schools marks were posted on a board in the lobby of the school in order from highest to lowest in terms of overall average. Every time a student passed through the lobby this board (which was huge) was viewed and it gave a lot of people motivation not to look stupid. It worked for me, I think it would work for others...
#6)
In a corroborative assignment is it extremely important for the teacher to make individuals roles for students and then mark the students individually and as a group. This is because often in group assignments the entire group suffers b/c of one persons work or visa versa the entire group does well because of one persons hard-work. The goal for group work is it work together to produce a solid final product but also to work evenly as individuals so no person is doing to much. When I would do group projects in school I either hated it or loved it based on my group. Because if I was with a bunch of hard-workers I wouldn't have to do anything and visa versa if I was with a bunch of slackers I would do the whole thing my self. And i feel this is not right. Marking semi-individually and giving individual tasks would allow the value of group work to be realized on a higher level.
WEEK 7 - Reading Week and the Class Before It
Over reading we it was our task to complete both our web-quest's and our own personal homepage. I managed to accomplish both and had fun while doing, learning a lot along the way. The web quest brought me back to my elementary school days and forced me to think about how I learned at that age. I did mine with my partner Newt on Global Warming and I think it would be fun and informative for students.
My personal webpage was easier to do and far more fun and creative. I used IWeb which made the process a joy and allowed the site to look more ascetically pleasing then i could have ever imagined. If i was to ever make a webpage again for any reason I would most definitely use IWeb.
I read the article “Revealing the Elephant: The Use and Misuse of Computers in Education” by Alen Key over the break as well. Key discussed the history of educating methods, he referred to everything from the historical methods of learning such as books and stories to more modern methods we know today like the computer, encyclopedia's and the Internet. Although to most it would seem like our new modern technologies have vastly improved our learning methods, Key argues the opposite saying that we our using our technology improperly and ineffectively and thus the advancements in technology being applied to education are going to waste. Key discusses the idea that the "journey is in the end the reward". Here states that with this technology we managed to skip the journey or figuring out why something is the way it is and we skip right to the answer, or we dont look at the history of how something came to be. This in the past has been the best way of learning, it builds strong understanding and fundamentals of concepts. We have come to rely too much on the ease and quickness that technology has given us when searching for an answer, and thus we do not learn why the answer is the what it is. He also mentions the misuse of computers in the classroom concerning things like video games and noneducational programs. He believes, and I agree, that even though you may have a computer in every class room, is it really being used to its full potential? Even though its there does that mean the students benefit from it? No must be instructed to use it in the correct manner, to accomplish specific tasks.
Overall reading week was fun. I went home to Toronto, saw a bunch of concerts and played a lot of hockey and basketball and I got to spend some time with my family which is always nice. It's always good to get a break, and I can' think I've anything I would have rather done.
WEEK 8 - SCRATCH
Last class started with a very informative speech made by an education professor. Watching this speech was the best thing that has happened in this class to date. His speech made so much sense and brought up some very good points about the problems with our education system and putting an emphasis on individual creativity. When he spoke about the inflation of education in terms of university degrees he couldn't be more right. Now a days graduating with a university degree means almost nothing and basically we our being educated to be professors rather then anything practical or creative. I think this is a huge flaw in our education system and it has without a doubt effected my life. I only wish my creativity and my strengths in school were encouraged, like sports, arts and computers. Instead I was forced to learn mostly about things I naturally had little ability with. I think out entire education system needs to be revamped and if it isnt, were going to be a world of trouble.
The next part of the class was equally as intriguing. Scratch was a program I never knew existed. In the past I've learned small bits of programming languages like C and HTML. Scratch basically dumbed down the language C making it interactive and making it common sense instead of programming knowledge. For example we used If and When and For loops in our creation of the cat chasing the ball. With C this would have taken me weeks to write (because im inexperienced) but with scratch it only took me a class to do. Its going to teach students about programming in a much simpler more effective way.
The music program we used next was amazing as well. These type of programs are the type of things that education systems need to have to promote creativity and individuality and to capture talent. The music program was a bit confusing to me, but i with a bit more time and if i had any music knowledge Im sure i could do very cool things with it.
My webpage and web quest are now online and uploaded onto the server... FINALLY Chapter 8 – Questions 1 and 3 What makes for an engaging and effective design challenge? Do Challenges with solutions that converge on a single ‘optimal’ solution violate the spirit of exploring a meaningful design space?
Yes and No... It's all situational. However I do believe that in most cases a challenge with one solution will take away from students ability to explore alternatives to the conventionally thought answer or solution to a problem. Most often in life there are more then one of way of doing things and also many different strategies of getting to a similar goal or solution to a problem. By creating a problem with one definitive answer you make things very black and white and leave no room for a grey creative area where the problem could be tackled from a different perspective. So many times in the history of the world, different outlooks on a problem of led to discoveries of talents, inventions, etc...
How can students be motivated to continue exploring, revising and refining their designs – to do meaningful interative design – when their common refrain is “It works, so I’m done”?
One way would be to judge creativity as a mark... Another would be to stress uniqueness of designs... But a good strategy would be to have a science fair type contest where designs are judged not based on if they work, but more how appealing they are, how interesting they are, and how innovative they are... Competition brings out the best in everyone, for the most part.
Week 9 – Powerpoint Visualizations with Technology
Chapter 9: Textbook Questions – 1, 2, and 4
1) Technology allows us to see the world in an entirely new way. Computers and computer software have revolutionized the way we see and interpret information. Presentations were changed by powerpoint. Spreadsheets by excel. Maps by map quest and google. And it just continues to evolve. For example, the software we in class last week with the bubbles that represented the data of countries to show trends in economic development. That software has changed stats and trends from mundane number on a piece of paper to visually simple way of understanding the same data. Even the program Scratch and the music program we used last week have changed C++ and music notes into an entirely new visual concept that allows us to see and interpret information differently.
2) Google is probably the best example of an entity that has redefined our concept of the world. Through various programs and features they implement on Google is able to actually create a global village out of the world. Google Earth is especially interesting. You can view the entire planet, get address, information of areas, view buildings in 3D. It gives an average person with the internet powers that couldn't have been dreamed of 10 years ago. Google Earth has made the world seem a lot smaller when we use its features, from our home we can view virtually the entire planet and find out information about what we are viewing. Someone who doesn't have the opportunity to travel can go on google earth and just whiz around the planet; they have created a global community.
4) According to the chapter in the textbook, students who have mathematical minds think best using visualization. This type of learning/thinking is best for solving math problems, geometry, graphs etc... I am not this type of thinker, and im actually quite bad at thinking this way. When im doing math, I find it hard to see the problems in my head, or do calculations in my head, and even if Im capable of doing them, I'm not quick. And its not surprise to me after reading this chapter, why Im bad at math. This type of learning can be practiced and should be taught to kids at a young age to promote and develop these skills. It will better allows kids to succeed at math and other areas of study that require visual learning.
Week 10 - Visualizing and Technology
Textbook Questions 5, 7, and 9
Is it ever possible to learn from television alone – that is, learn how to do something merely from watching television instruction? What meaning will it have after only watching the show? What meaning will it have after you try it yourself?
Yes. Well it most certainly works for me. I've learned more about general knowledge, life experiences, and skills then possibly any other medium of technology. T.V shows have taught me about interpersonal relationships and other life lessons, as a kid I learned to read and count from shows like Sesame Street, and instructional shows have taught me various skills which I still remember to this day. Two great examples would be when I watch The Food Network and when I watch Hockey Night in Canada and then show the instructional segment with Ron Mclean and Kirk Muller. With The Food Network on various occasions I have not only learned how to cook something I didn't know how to cook, I have learned different skills involving preparation methods, grilling techniques, how to marinade something properly etc... Through watching I learn these skills and then when I go and put them to use in the kitchen and after a little practice on my own I've mastered the skills. By just watching the T.V and not practicing, I still learn and still gain knowledge but I still dont have the first hand experience necessary to be fully proficient with the skill. The same goes with the instructional hockey segment of Hockey Night in Canada. They teach skills during the segment and more often then not after watching and making sense of there explanations and what I see, I have performed these skills flawlessly when playing hockey in the near future; proof that one can learn from instructional television.
Video production is a constructivist activity; that is, students are learning by constructing an artifact. What other kinds of constructivist activities can you think of using?
When growing up in middle school we were required to take Shop Class and Home Eq. Both involved constructing an artifact and I learned a lot of from both. In Shop I used to tools and machines to build devices of wood and hydraulic tubing. Through creating my final project which was a mini put machine, I learned a lot about design, the science of engineering, safety, teamwork and how to use tools and machines properly. In Home Eq our projects involved sewing and involved cooking. Cooking ended up being one of passions in life today, and I have this class to thank. I learned i lot about design and presentation from sewing (and how to use the machines) and from cooking I learned the basics of baking, how to use a oven, how to sauté, how to blend, how to chop etc... These are all skills I have carried on throughout my life.
Video feedback has been called a “mirror with a memory.” Why is seeing yourself on television such a compelling and incisive experience? How do you see yourself? Why is that so powerful?
It is is so powerful because it allows one to see them self as the rest of the world sees them and allows one to be there own critique. This helps develop the skills as you can see what you are doing wrong for yourself and thus can work on exactly what you view as being a problem. For me, I have had this experience first hand. I am an avid water skier and at a younger age was even competitive with it. But it wasn't until I watched a video of myself doing a water skiing course, that I took the jump to becoming the skier I am today. By watching myself, I corrected all these fundamental errors people were trying to explain to me, but I couldn't fix because it didn't look to myself like I was doing anything wrong. Having video footage of myself, made me my own critique and allowed me to fully understand what I needed to improve by viewing my flaws.
Weekly Reflection
Best class of the year hands down. This class taught me a skill I will most definetly continue to refine and will for sure use for recreational and academic purposes later in life. We got to mess around with movie maker and got to go and make a movie. I loved the freedom in this class and had a ton of fun making the movie I made with Alicia, Jess, and Dave. Although, I swore in the movie, (and I'd like the apologize for that), I thought we did a good job for our first time with the program. I'm still learning how to use the program better and eventually If i am able to afford my own camera, I think skills I've learned are going to allow me to create some amazing movies with the program. After watching others and my own video I saw that there was much I could do to make mine better the lightening, sound, clarity and picture was not amazing and next time I make a movie I will keep those things in mind.
No complaints about the class, I enjoyed watching others movies and I had a great time.
Week 11 – Digital Storytelling
There were no questions from the textbook for this week, however I did read and enjoy Barrett's article. She talked about electronic portfolios and what goes into making them and the skills necessary to create an effective one. Many of these skills are ones that we have implemented into creating power point presentations, and more recently with our movies. Also she discussed, preparing before creating portfolios, and suggested things one should ask themselves before creating the content of a portfolio. This questions could be changed around a bit and applied to creating power point presentations, websites, and movies.
As for this last class, it was quite enjoyable, and involved us becoming more familiar with movie editing and gave us time to work on our final project. Me and David, got the idea from you to make a video of us presenting our powerpoint presentation. We made this power point this semester for a marketing class and worked extremely hard on it. It didn't incorporate buttons but since we didn't need to go back and forth to guide our way through the presentation it didn't really need buttons. The montage at the beginning was especially difficult to create and by adding sound to it, it looked even more professional. We had a combination of images of the BMW 3-Series and powerful words to describe it going back and fourth simultaneously using effects from powerpoint to create an almost video like look that gave our powerpoint a very exciting and strong start. This class we looked into finding programs to allow us to capture a video of the screen while we present the powerpoint. I found a few programs, and Im going to try them out this week on my spare time.
Week 12 – Assessing Meaningful Learning with Technology
Textbook Chapter 10 – Questions 1, 2 and 3
Is assessment really a separate activity from learning? What circumstances may impact whether it is or isn’t?
Although I do believe them to be technically separate activities, assessment is an integral part of then learning process. Without assessment learning would not develop as efficiently and effectively. And, without learning, there would be nothing to assess. So they are separate but they are interdependent. With out proper assessment, learning can be effected, you need to be criticized in order to learn from your mistakes and realize what you don't know and what you are doing wrong. Circumstances that impact if assessment is separate from activity depend on what kind of learning and what is being learned. At times, with simple tasks no assessment is necessary to learn. But with tasks that involves complex skills like learning a hockey skill, you need assessment as a part of learning to properly learn that skill.
How do you use assessment activities as a way to generate feedback that can improve learner performance? After reading this chapter, are there ways you can see how technology can contribute to this?
Assessment involves both a positive and negative (constructive) assessment. Both can improve a learners performance, but they key is giving a balance between positive and negative and to watch what you say when you say it. Too much positive will not allow for improvement and too much negative will halt improvement because the learner will be unenthused. Technology can contribute to assessment and feedback and in number of way. The primary ones discussed in this chapter were e-portfolios, clickers, and rubrics. All of these technologies can easily integrated into the classroom and will make for great forms of feedback. One used heavily when I was in high school and still at times in university is the rubric. This offers categorized feedback which is the most effective as is gives students specific assessment on different aspects of their work.
How can you use technology to make assessment activities less threatening to learners or maybe even a positive experience?
The best way to make assessment more positive is to not put a huge weight on the assessment, and allow the students to be comfortable with the way they are being assessed and the technology being used. Another way to make it positive is to make the feedback (both the look and comment of the feedback) less intimidating. Be kind and warm yet constructive in our feedback not generic and cold like some technology feels it.
Week 12 Reflection: Assessment with Technology and Final Project’s
This was pretty much the last class, sigh*. And it was relaxing to boot, which was nice. I spent the class working on my final project with David and we made some progress. Also, we got to see one other persons final project which was nice and gave me a perspective on how I want to do my own project.
Jason Sterling
260185433
EDTP-200
Integrating Technology into Physical Education
Throughout the duration of this class we have discussed various ways in which technology, if implemented correctly, can allow for a more efficient and effective learning experience in a classroom environment. As well, we also discussed how creative intelligence has been undermined in education by the lack of importance placed on less scholarly subjects such as, Physical Education, Art and Music. Personally, I feel by creativity and excellence in these strains of intelligence could be drastically improved if technology was incorporated into these areas of study. The following paper will describe specifically how technology can be integrated into Physical Education by analyzing four resources: a web quest, two Internet articles, and an interview with an experienced Physical Education teacher.
1) A web quest
http://www.freewebs.com/mscarmon/mainmenu.htm
This web quest is geared towards students in grade 7 – 9 (middle school) and provides some very interesting information about how technology can be used in physical education. The site offers a five-day program for physical education students where each day a new task is given to complete that involves technology and physical education. As well, a survey is given to the teacher at the beginning asking preliminary questions to see which types of technology the teacher is familiar with and which types are already being used to promote a better physical education class. Some of the main ideas that are discussed in this web quest is how to properly use heart monitors, how to keep track of progress using excel, how to teach skills using power point and how to use online quizzes to check understanding.
This resource conjures up some great ideas and is very descriptive in explaining how they should be used. However, I feel better use of technology could be possible and I feel they didn’t have enough ideas on the topic. Some aspects I felt could have improved this web quest would be if they explained how video footage could help correct flaws in the fundamentals of certain skills and how workout technology could help keep students in better shape.
As teacher trying to improve my class, I would follow the five-day program they explain and see the results. Also, I would take the survey at the beginning and see what parts of the classroom I could start using technology in effectively. The web quest also offers background information on many technology subjects and offers links to other web quest. I feel that reading through these would allow me to be more knowledgeable when teaching students and thus have a more effective classroom.
2) Journal Article:
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_hb3218/is_200409/ai_n13130827
This article discusses how integrating technology into physical education classes is an important goal for the American government. As well, it discusses the importance of using technology to teach physical education in our modern world and why we must start to stray away from traditional methods of teaching physical education. The majority of the article discusses the importance of training teachers in college to use technology in the classroom.
The article suggests that physical education teachers must be more familiar with computer programs and Internet application to better implement these aspects into physical education and health education. One example of a suggestion they make is using excel to make a healthy weight/height/performance tracking application and to make the program goal orientated for students.
As a teacher I would improve my classroom by taking a step back and enhancing my own ability to use technology. The article describes how programs with technology in other countries have an edge on the USA’s physical education system and technology is stated as one of the main reasons why. To become a superior teacher and to improve the lives of my students I would retrain myself to come up with new methods of how to use technology in physical education.
3) Website: http://www.pesoftware.com/Technews/news.html
This site describes how to effectively use a camcorder to teach skills and safety in physical education. The site starts with talking about how to select and use a camcorder properly and then moves on to a sample lesson plan. The example they use in the lesson plan is how to teach archery safety and skills to a class incorporating the use of a camcorder.
I think is a great resource for any physical education teacher. The concept of a camcorder being used to teach skills and safety can be incorporated into any aspect of the physical education curriculum.
If I were a teacher this would with out a doubt be a crucial resource for me. Using video footage to teach students is probably the best way to teach them. Most people learn visually and by turning instructions into a movie, I feel not only would students listen better, but they would also absorb the information better too.
4) Interview with Physical Education teacher: Mr. Bidak
Mr. Bidak has been teaching Physical Education at Crescent School in Toronto for over 30 years and has just recently retired. He was my middle school gym teacher and homeroom teacher, and thus I learned a lot about health and sports from him. In this interview, conducted over the phone, I asked him a few question about the importance of technology in physical education and what he would recommend for future teachers. He told me how he had witnessed a complete evolution of the way physical education was taught with the advent of technology in the classroom. Although Mr Bidak is now in his late sixties, he still explained how near the end of his career he still managed to keep up-to-date with technology and how it helped him and his students a lot. He explained how he kept track of marks, progress, and health statistic using excel. He explained the use of the beep test (a running drill that uses tape-recorded evaluation system) to track the physical fitness of his students. He also declared that the right technology when working out is crucial development of physical fitness. Although he told me he felt giving instructions face to face rather then using video footage would be more effective, he admitted that using a video camera to capture individual students flaws when performing skills would be a huge help to correcting there mistakes and would work far better then he himself explaining the flaws.